Graco 4Ever vs Chicco NextFit Zip are two convertible car seats available in the same price range. They are relatively expensive if compared to the other models in the market, but they come with superior features and quality. So, between Graco 4Ever and Chicco NextFit Zip, which one is actually better? Find out below!
What we are going to discuss in this article include:
– The comparison of these car seats’ dimensions
– How long that you will be able to use each car seat
– The installation system on each model
– The comparison of their harness systems
– The features and safety of Graco 4Ever vs Chicco NextFit Zip
– The available color choices on each model
– Which convertible car seat that is generally more recommended
The first difference between these two convertible car seats that you need to consider is their overall dimensions. This is very important if you have a small car or if you want to fit two or three units across the backseat. Most people prefer a car seat that is light and doesn’t eat up too much leg room.See also: Graco Extend2Fit vs Chicco NextFit.
Graco 4Ever is quite bulky and heavy. It measures 21.5 inches wide, 20 inches deep, and 24 inches tall. It won’t allow you to fit three units across the backseat, but you can fit two units across just fine. It doesn’t take too much leg room, but keep in mind that it will require more space when reclined. The weight is about 22.75 lbs.
Actually, for an all-in-one convertible car seat, it is fairly compact and lightweight; but this doesn’t change the fact that Graco 4Ever requires more room than Chicco NextFit Zip to set up. As a note, it is FAA-approved when used with the harness system, so you can use it on an airplane seat although the size and weight may make it not very practical for traveling.
Chicco NextFit Zip is quite slimmer, but it is both taller and heavier. This model measures 19 inches wide, 21 inches deep, and 29.2 inches tall. It also won’t allow you to fit three units across, but you can use two units on the backseat easily. Note that this model will take quite some leg room when used behind the driver’s seat in a small car.
This model is even heavier at 25.1 lbs. You can still use it on an airplane because it is FAA-approved, but it is not the most practical solution for traveling with your child due to the size and weight. If you really need to use it on an airplane, you need to check the width of the seat to make sure this unit can fit there.
Perhaps the biggest difference between Graco 4Ever vs Chicco NextFit Zip is their built-in modes. Graco 4Ever is a four-in-one model, whereas Chicco NextFit Zip is a two-in-one model. In other words, Graco 4Ever will probably remain usable for a longer time than Chicco NextFit Zip.
Graco 4Ever is a four-in-one convertible car seat which can serve as a rear-facing infant car seat, a forward-facing harnessed car seat, a high-back booster seat, and a backless booster seat. It has 6 recline positions which will allow you to use it for a newborn or small baby and to enhance the comfort for a larger kid.
In the rear-facing mode, it is suitable for a baby between 4 – 40 lbs; the child’s head must be at least one inch below the top of the headrest. In the forward-facing mode, it is suitable for a toddler between 20 – 65 lbs. In the high-back booster mode, it is suitable for a kid between 30 – 100 lbs. In the backless booster mode, it is suitable for a kid between 40 – 120 lbs. The maximum height limit is 57 inches.
So, you will be able to use Graco 4Ever for a very long time. It will probably remain usable until your child no longer needs a car seat; but keep in mind that it has an expiration date of 10 years since the manufacture date.
Chicco NextFit Zip is a two-in-one convertible car seat. It starts as a rear-facing car seat, then it can convert into a forward-facing car seat after your child has become taller and bigger. It has 9 recline positions. However, it doesn’t convert into a booster seat, which means that you will need to buy a dedicated booster seat in the future.
In the rear-facing mode, Chicco NextFit Zip is suitable for a baby between 5 – 40 lbs. As usual, the child’s head should be at least one inch below the top of the headrest for proper safety. In the forward-facing mode, it is suitable for a child between 22 – 65 lbs. The maximum height limit is 49 inches.
As you can see, the maximum height limit is lower than that of Graco4Ever. So, your child will probably outgrow this car seat more quickly, especially if your child is quite tall. The expiration date is not stated, but most products remain good for more than 5 years.
Next, Graco 4Ever vs Chicco NextFit Zip come with different installation systems. Each works with each own proprietary technology that is designed to allow easy and quick set up.
Graco 4Ever comes with the InRight LATCH system. It works with the vehicle’s latch connectors. It is indeed very easy to use; the company claims that you only need one second to attach the latch connector properly. The installation is quite solid and secure. Alternatively, it can also be installed using the vehicle’s seatbelt.
Adjusting the recline is also very easy. On the side, there are color-coded indicators that show you the ideal recline level for every seat position. So, there is no guesswork in the set up.
Chicco NextFit Zip, on the other hand, comes with premium latch connectors and the Super Cinch tightener. By using the Super Cinch tightener, you can easily tighten the latch connectors without much effort. As the effect, achieving a completely solid and secure installation that doesn’t wiggle around is very easy. Alternatively, you can also use the Lock Sure system for an installation with the vehicle’s seatbelt; this system also works very well in tightening and securing the car seat.
As expected, this car seat also allows you to adjust the recline easily. It is equipped with the dual Ride Right bubble indicators to allow you to verify whether the recline angle is in the proper level or not. These indicators work well and are practical in use.
Graco 4Ever is incredibly easy to use, thanks to the Simply Safe Adjust Harness System. It is designed to let you adjust the harness fit without manually re-threading the harness straps. Hence, it is very convenient and practical to use. You can adjust the headrest and harness position in one motion using a single hand.
Chicco NextFit Zip is also very easy to use. It also has its own easy-adjust no-rethread harness system. It has a pull tightener for adjusting the harness fit on your child and nine selectable headrest positions. So, it will be able to accommodate your child easily throughout the years as your child grows.
Features and Safety
Now, let’s compare the features of Graco 4Ever vs Chicco NextFit Zip. For sure, both models have been tested to meet or exceed the federal safety standards, so they both are able to provide adequate protection.
Graco 4Ever comes with two integrated cup holders where you can put your child’s milk bottle, your own water bottle, or some snacks. All of the fabrics are removable, and you can wash them in a washing machine. So, you don’t need to worry about the cleaning and maintenance.
Graco 4Ever has a steel-reinforced frame for structural integrity in any condition. It has lots of energy-absorbing EPS foam pads to shield the occupant against crash forces. The sidewalls are really thick and tough. This model has been side-impact tested. It can withstand extreme car interior temperatures, and it has a peak crash force of approximately 2X the federal car seat standard.
Chicco NextFit Zip comes with a removable cup holder. You can detach the cup holder when you need to free up some space. It is very easy to clean; it features the Zip & Wash seat pad which is easy to remove. You just need to unzip the seat pad from the shell and throw the thing into your washing machine.
Chicco NextFit Zip also comes with a steel-reinforced frame and energy-absorbing EPS foam sidewalls. Besides the federal safety standard, it has also been side-impact tested to ensure proper safety and protection.
Graco 4Ever has plenty of color options. There are at least 12 different variants, which are Matrix, Hayden, Cameron, Dorian, Bryce, Azalea, Basin, Kylie, Ottlie, Studio, Tambi, and Skylar.
Chicco NextFit Zip does provide some color options. There are at least 5 different variants. They are Eclipse, Spectrum, Midnight, Traction, and Starlet.
Graco 4Ever vs Chicco NextFit Zip
Between these two models, Graco 4Ever is more recommended. It will remain usable for a longer time, as it can convert into a forward-facing harnessed car seat, high-back booster, and backless booster. It also has a long expiration date. It is very easy to install and use, and it offers excellent safety for your child.