Graco is one of the most renowned manufacturers of infant car seats. There are good reasons to trust their products. Now, if you are looking for a convertible infant car seat that can grow with your baby, you may be interested in Graco Extend2Fit vs 4Ever. Below, you can read the detailed comparison between these two models. So, continue reading!
What we will discuss in this article include:
– The dimensions of each infant car seat
– The suitable uses of each model
– Whether these models are easy to install or not
– The seat features of Graco Extend2Fit vs 4Ever
– The safety and protection of each infant car seat
– Which model that is generally more recommended
First of all, let’s take a look at the dimensions of these two models. Handling an infant car seat inside a small car can be quite challenging. Things become even more difficult if you need to use two infant car seats at the same time. Hence, most people prefer infant car seats that are compact and lightweight. See also: Britax Advocate vs Boulevard.
Graco Extend2Fit is interesting because it comes with a more compact design. It looks slimmer and more streamlined. However, note that it is quite long, so it will require more space especially in the rear facing mode. This model actually measures 19.2 inches wide, 25.2 inches deep, and 22.1 inches tall.
Furthermore, Graco Extend2Fit has an extendable footrest. If you extend the footrest, you will add another 5 inches in front of the seat. So, this model is not really ideal if your car isn’t spacious.
Graco 4Ever initially looks wider and bulkier. However, the shape is not as long as Graco Extend2Fit’s. It will require slightly more lateral space, but it will not eat up as much space in front of it. This model actually measures 20 inches wide, 21.5 inches deep, and 24 inches tall. You can use Graco 4Ever easily in the rear facing mode.
The next important thing to consider when choosing between Graco Extend2Fit vs 4Ever is the type of the convertible infant car seat that you want to buy. Graco Extend2Fit is a two-in-one infant car seat, which means that it can be used rear-facing or forward-facing. Meanwhile, Graco 4Ever is an all-in-one infant car seat. Besides having rear-facing and forward-facing modes, you can also use this model as a booster seat.
Graco Extend2Fit has a rear-facing mode which is suitable for a child of up to 50 pounds. You can use the rear-facing mode until your child is 45 inches tall. Once your child passes the weight limit or the height limit, you need to use the forward-facing mode, which is suitable for a child of up to 65 pounds of 49 inches tall. Graco Extend2Fit can’t be used as a booster seat.
Graco 4Ever is awesome because you can use it continuously until your child no longer requires a car seat. The rear-facing mode is suitable for a child of up to 40 pounds. The forward-facing mode is suitable for a child of up to 65 pounds or 52 inches tall. Afterwards, you can use it as a booster seat.
The high-back booster seat mode is suitable until your child’s weight reaches 100 pounds or 57 inches tall. Meanwhile, the backless booster seat mode can hold your child until he or she reaches 120 pounds, but the height limit remains the same which is 57 inches tall. Graco 4Ever is an excellent long-term solution that you can use since your child’s infancy.
Many parents consider the installation of an infant car seat as a daunting task. This is understandable. Many products in the market are difficult to install, and many of them keep wobbling around no matter what you do. In fact, the National Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) mentioned that about 75% of infant car seats are installed incorrectly. You certainly don’t want to risk your child’s safety just because of a ridiculously difficult installation mechanism.
So, between Graco Extend2Fit vs 4Ever, which model is easier to install and use? Fortunately, both of them come with Graco’s proprietary InRight LATCH System. This installation system is very simple, quick, yet effective. It is foolproof. You can install either model by using a one-second attachment which gives an audible click once the seat and the base are connected properly. This installation system is convenient and reliable.
That said, Graco Extend2Fit is a bit more difficult to be installed in the forward-facing position. This is mostly because of the size. You need to be more patient. Also, you may be unable to use the extendable footrest in some cars. Graco 4Ever does not have such problem; you can install it easily in the rear-facing position, forward-facing position, and booster seat mode.
Once installed and you hear the click, these infant car seats are really solid and secure. They just don’t wobble around. Even if your baby is very active and moving in the seat, they won’t budge. So, you don’t need to worry about the installation. Even so, both Graco Extend2Fit and Graco 4Ever can be easily detached with one click as well.
Recline and Harness System
One important thing to look for when choosing an infant car seat is a reclining seat. Your infant child won’t be able to sit in an upright position – this is very bad and dangerous. So, you need to choose a model that reclines. Note that newborn babies require a fully flat position.
Each of these two models has 6 recline positions. They both can be fully reclined. Graco Extend2Fit and Graco 4Ever can be used for newborn babies if used with the newborn inserts. You need to use the newborn inserts to make sure that your child won’t move around. Both infant car seats have lots of padding, so they can keep newborn babies comfy and protected.
Furthermore, both Graco Extend2Fit and Graco 4Ever come with the company’s Simply Safe Adjust Harness System. With this harness system, you can effortlessly adjust the position of the headrest and harness in one motion. This is incredibly convenient. It doesn’t involve any re-threading, which most if not all parents hate.
Both models have 5-point harness systems to ensure that your child’s vital points are properly secured. Each of these infant car seats has 10 selectable headrest/harness positions to provide optimal comfort and safety. So, you can easily adjust the system to suit your child’s physicality as they grow.
Most parents know that infant car seats sometimes need to deal with spills and other nasty incidents. Cleaning a dirty infant car seat can be quite a challenge – some models seem to keep stains forever. Fortunately, both Graco Extend2Fit vs 4Ever have machine-washable seat pads. What a life-saver! Both models are very easy to clean and maintain. You only need to remove the seat pads and throw them into your washing machine. Let the seat pads dry before putting them back on.
Each of these two models has two integrated cup holders. You can put your baby’s milk bottle and water bottle there. Cup holders may seem trivial, but they are actually very important as you need to be able to reach the milk and water bottles easily.
One distinctive feature between Graco Extend2Fit and Graco 4Ever is the footrest. Graco Extend2Fit comes with a three-position extension footrest. You can add up to 5 inches of additional leg room for your child. If your child has a large physicality, he or she will find this nice and comfortable. But, as mentioned above, the extendable footrest may create additional challenges in the installation.
Graco 4Ever does not have an extendable footrest. However, this is not necessarily a serious disadvantage. Without the extendable footrest, most children will still find it comfortable. And, without the extendable footrest, the infant car seat is easier to install and use.
In terms of safety, Graco’s products are not to be underestimated. Both Graco Extend2Fit and Graco 4Ever provide exceptional safety. Graco’s products have been tested extensively according to the US standards before they are released – and they have proven to be able to hold up in real-life crash incidents.
The construction uses a highly durable steel frame. The seat is equipped with impact-absorbing foam. The design of each infant car seat here is also optimized to shield the baby from potential debris particles.
One complaint is just that some parents find the harness straps difficult to tighten. However, there is a useful method that you can use with either Graco Extend2Fit or Graco 4Ever. You need to pull up the harness of the hip area first, then the harness behind the car seat, and finally the adjuster strap. You need to tighten the harness first before buckling the chest clip.
Graco Extend2Fit vs 4Ever
In general, Graco 4Ever is more recommended. This model is more compact and more versatile. It is an all-in-one car seat which can be used rear-facing, forward-facing, or as a booster seat. You can use it since your child’s infancy until they no longer need a car seat.