Safety 1st Guide 65 vs Cosco Scenera Next

Taking the baby or toddler to travel in a car will need suitable safety equipment. One of the important things is selecting a suitable car seat according to their weight and age. Of course, there are many types of car seats available in the market, but not everyone will bring suitable features as needed. Such as when comparing between Safety 1st Guide 65 VS Cosco Scenera Next. Both are a recommended brand and bring a good satisfying result when used. However, you may need to select one between them. To get the best overview and information on buying, the next paragraph will explain more on the specific details, advantages and many more.

General Brand Overview

Both products are quite well-known brands in the motherhood world. They both have many years of experience in providing baby needs, including to produce a suitable car seat that meets the standard safety and comfortable feeling. Therefore, whether selecting Cosco or Safety 1st, there shouldn’t be too many issues in terms of safety and warranty. The only thing that needs to compare and consider is the offered features. As they have a similar feature but also have different details. For further information, check on the below paragraphs. Read also: Cosco Scenera Next vs Cosco Apt 50

General Specification

As mentioned before that, both products bring their specialty features on their car seat. Such as if you look at Safety 1st Guide 65, the brand offers you various benefits and features such as rear-racing mode or forward-facing mode. The same way with Cosco Scenera Next that design for the same purpose. However, even if they are capable of performing a similar task, it has different limitations and details the pros and cons. This is captured on the below information.

Pros and Cons of Safety 1st Guide 65

Each product has its strengths, but each product also has its weaknesses. Therefore, parents need to make sure which one is stronger with less weakness. As an example, the Safety 1st Guide claim below pros to their consumer.

  • The car seat is more lightweight.
  • It has tall top harness slots.
  • It is easy to install mainly using a seat belt or LATCH connectors.
  • The product is quite narrow and efficient in place.
  • It can install with rear-facing mode for older babies or also toddlers who can sit up unassisted.

However, the brand also consists of several cons that also need to consider too. The lack is including:

  • It doesn’t fit newborns/small babies well. Therefore, you will need another brand for it.
  • LATCH belt gets caught on the hook where the elastic loop belongs.
  • Headrest pushes the head forward.
  • The harness is tough to adjust.
  • Requires pool noodles or rolled-up towel when installing rear-facing.
  • Basics and Measurements: EPS foam 5 harness slots (4 for rear-facing, 3 for forward-facing)
  • Expired years up to 10 years’ expiration.
  • FAA-approved.
  • Harness slots: 9.5”, 11.5”, 13.5”, 15.5, 17”.
  • Buckle slots: 3.25, 4.5”, 6”.
  • Internal seat height: 24”.
  • Seat pan depth: 11.5”.
  • External widest width: 18.5”.
  • Weight: 11.3 lbs.
  • LATCH anchor weight limits: 40 lbs.

Pros and Cons of Safety 1st Guide 65

It is a different way with Cosco Scenera Next that also claims for some pros but also has some cons at the same time. The positive advantage of using the product including:

  • The weight includes a very lightweight.
  • Fits infants well.
  • It can install easily through the lower LATCH connectors.
  • The product is quite narrow and efficient in place.
  • It can install with rear-facing mode for older babies or also toddlers who can sit up unassisted.

While if we look further on the design and specification, apparently the product also has several cons that still need to be understood too. The lack of this product such as:

  • Single continuous harness strap.
  • Low top harness slots mean the seat will be outgrown quickly in the forward-facing position.
  • Can only use the 2 inner buckle positions when rear-facing.
  • Basics and Measurements: 5 harness slots.
  • Completed with an expiration date up to 8-year expired.
  • FAA-approved.
  • Harness slots: 5.5”, 7.5”, 9.5”, 11.5”, 13.5”.
  • Buckle slots: 2.5”, 4”, 5.5”.
  • Internal seat height: 24”.
  • Seat pan depth: 11”.
  • External widest width: 17 ¼”.
  • Weight: 7.0 lbs.
  • LATCH can be used to a maximum of 40 lbs. weight only.


In terms of price, both have quite a difference in retail price. As information, you will be able to get Cosco Scenera Next with only $45, but you will need to spend a minimum of $80 to get Safety 1st Guide 65. Therefore, you will get what you paid in this case. With more budget or money, you can get not only safety but an absolute more comfortable material than the cheaper one.

Safety 1st Guide 65 vs Cosco Scenera Next

- Perfect for smaller cars or for extra space in your larger vehicle, this LATCH equipped Safety 1st car seat accommodates children from 5 to 40 pounds in rear facing mode and from 22 to 65 pounds in forward facing mode
- Adjust the 5 point harness from the front of the seat
- Side impact protection built into this infant car seat keeps your little one extra secure
- Three of these seats can fit side by side in the back seat of most cars, perfect for growing families and carpools
- Rear-facing 5-40 lbs (19" to 40")
- 5 harness heights and 3 buckle locations allow for the best fit for growing children
- Forward-facing 22-40 lbs (29" to 43") and at least 2 years old
- Seat pad is machine washable and dryer safe


Finally, the comparison above will help to bring you an overview of what is better than the other one. It is not said that selecting between Safety 1st Guide 65 VS Cosco Scenera Next will manage a huge difference. But, you need to consider which one is not only safe for a long trip but also feels comfortable to accompany your child’s journey. Not to mention the age of your child, as the one can use longer than the other.

Therefore, if you prefer to wear the car seat for the long term and long age, then you need to consider Safety 1st Guide 65. It covers your child up to 65 pounds and 49 inches. While if you choose Cosco Scenera Next, you should be happy to use it only up to 40 pounds and 43 inches.

After reading carefully the features and pros or cons of each product, now you can see and select the most suitable product for your child. Always remember that better quality and service will ask you for more payment. That is why Safety 1st Guide with longer using age asking you for more money. But in case you plan to use a short duration of the car seat or plan to change it with another better brand than a cheaper product might suit your selection. Here you can choose Cosco Scenera Next and use it for fewer years.